Bill I have some new advice for you. This is just my observation. I would look at control issues in myself if I were you. Communication is when person A says want they want, person B responds how they want. When person A want to speak freely, but also wants control of person B's words-that is called CONTROL. Now you are displeased that people are too nice. It could go the other way as well.
I have a good friend that has OCD and some very unhealthy thinking patterns. For the most part, we keep our communication on the superficial level because of that. She will have hurt feelings over her grown daughters. An example is that her daughter was having marital problems and she was very meddling, once she was going to write a letter to her son in law about her daughter including her daughters faults.. I told her it was a bad idea and why. She said she was going to do it and did.
Her duaghter was off work and read the letter and she was in a mess. She proceeds to tell me about the conversation but first tells me, "I just want you to listen, I dont want any comments" I agreed and didnt say a word. However, she could have just as well shared it with the wall. She often wants to vent. She is unreasonable about her kids and grandkids. Her hoardering affects the relationship, etc, but as her friend, I occassionally need to be honest at any cost.
I have told her truths about what I see, how her list of shoulds might cause depression. I have compared hoardering to other addictions. I have done so very gently. She has gotten mad and turned it to my relationship with my kids. I can take it because I am not that sensative and am human, have made mistakes, and would do things differently. However, she, like many people want to vent, but do not want to hear anything that would make them less than perfect. She is a control freak in every way, and I love her just the same. She would do anything for me and I for her. But I also know, that if I told it how it is sometimes, she would probably write me off, as she has with one of her daughters.
As someone else on this thread stated earlier, honesty has caused bad feelings. I do think that some of us with ptsd have been tamed by others reaction. At least this friend that I described is honest about it, but I have had manipulative people twist my words.
Bill I think some people have been attacked(her or otherwise) for giving opinions and advice. That is up to them to heal-however, I think it sure gives me something to think about. On the other hand, it is their response-they gave it-you dont get to pick their words.