• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Take Out The Bad, Put In The Good

  • Post starter Post starter Deleted member 1860
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Deleted member 1860

Hi all,

I'm wondering if anyone else is taking an approach similar to mine.

I am currently seeing my therapist every other week, and my pastor on the weeks that I'm not seeing my therapist. They have my permission to speak with one another, per my pastor's request as she isn't qualified to handle deeper issues and if something more serious should arise, she wants my permission to contact my therapist. It also helps them to be on the same page in terms of my healing.

Both of them are in agreement that my therapist works on removing the "bad" trauma aspects while my pastor works on adding the "good" in terms of spirituality. (There is a story in the bible about this, something about vanquishing demons from a house, the house being empty, yadda yadda yadda, and needing to fill it with good. Sorry, although I was raised in the church, I'm not up on my bible stories after being gone for almost 20 years!) My pastor says that if you don't fill your life with the "good" then its much easier for the "bad" to come creeping back in. I tend to agree with this approach, and so far it has served me well.

This is a new approach to me, for the most part. Yes, most therapists will advise doing positive things in your life, but this approach is a bit different, in that both aspects are equally important. For me, at least, in the past, therapy and healing has been mostly about removing the bad and not so much about adding the good. In the sense that, for example, even doing something like correcting faulty thinking via CBT is done simply to fix something bad, not done in the sense that its something good for the sake of something good. KWIM? (I hope I'm being clear!)

And even if you're not religious or spiritual, perhaps you can identify with this approach as well, in that you're doing other things to fill the "void" left by the "absence" of trauma. (Yes, I say absence in that for many of us, for so long, our lives have revolved around trauma, so when the symptoms disappear, we are left with, well, to be frank, a whole lot more time on our hands!)

Thanks!
 
I do a lot of volunteer driving. It helped me recover from my trauma, T used to challenge me to do x number of drives per week. So, it helped me, helped others, gave me confidence and helped to make me feel better about myself.
 
Hi ScaredofLonely,

Yes, focusing on things that are positive, good, beautiful, kind, etc. is a great way to make positive changes in, not only in your mood, but how you view life.

I am sorry that CBT left you with a void, as I have learned to change my negative or distorted thinking styles and replace them with realistic and/or more positive. It is the same with my perception of things, in that they are not ALL bad or ALL good. There is a mix and unfortunately, trauma leaves a person with tunnel vision sometimes, where we shut out the good.

Keep working at it as it really does help in the long run.
 
Yes replacing negative memories with happy ones, however small. It takes energy and practise I find, too. Or more accurately, to replace with the good feelings, or trust, or peace, or what-have-you, of the memory (even if not all the details itself), if that makes sense.
 
I am learning to focus on the good and the positive. It is helping me alot. I am very grateful to the people on this site because so much is geared towards improvement and good quality of life. I have grown alot since I joined up in Febuary. It is so hard to believe how much my life has improved.
 
I am sorry that CBT left you with a void, as I have learned to change my negative or distorted thinking styles and replace them with realistic and/or more positive. It is the same with my perception of things, in that they are not ALL bad or ALL good. There is a mix and unfortunately, trauma leaves a person with tunnel vision sometimes, where we shut out the good.

Keep working at it as it really does help in the long run.

I think that maybe I wasn't exactly clear... As I don't know exactly how to word this myself!

Its not so much a failure of CBT per se, rather that simply putting in good thoughts isn't enough, as it doesn't fill the space of where the trauma once was.

Its more like the spirituality fills you up in a way that nothing else ever could.

Interestingly, my pastor and I had a discussion of who did therapy before modern psychotherapy... Pastors and priests...duh, I can't believe I missed that one, lol. So for me things have come full circle, I am getting the most I can out of modern therapy and receiving spiritual guidance as well.
 
Even though my trauma was partially religion-based, I love how your t and pastor are working together. This seems like a very healthy collaboration and I'm happy it is working for you. I would love to see more people from the scientific realm and the spirituality realm cooperating, rather than fighting.

While this may never work for me directly, hearing about gives me a little bit more hope for the world. Wish you the best.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom