• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Childhood Being hit with a hair brush-abuse?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Scarlet13

Platinum Member
Hi,
So I know there have been many posts of this nature before.
Is being hit with a brush as punishment abuse?
If something is done as punishment does that make it abuse? Meaning planned with the parent being calm doing it for the "child's own good."
What if you are living in the South where it is strict and this seems to be acceptable practice? Still abuse?
 
Hello. I hope this helps. Abuse
There also are several research studies that have been done on children who were abused, revealing that, as adults, children who were hit developed psychological and relationship problems.

I knew being hit was wrong because I saw criminal T.V. shows and movies where parents and other adults were summoned in court and being sent to jail for hitting their children. Also, I knew that my friends' parents didn't physically abuse them, nor their spouse, when they did (and even when they didn't) do anything wrong. Mine were either grounded or sent to their room. My kind teachers, who didn't abuse any of my classmates, also helped me, by their example, that it wasn't normal for other adults to treat their children like that.

Also, another clue that it's wrong is, notice that abusive relatives demand their children to be perfectly behaved, without expressing emotion, like an adult (when that's not developmentally possible for children because their brains aren't developed, yet, because they're not adults), yet think it's okay that they can hit others, fly off the handle, and shout at them, acting like children themselves?

Just like the Nassar abuse survivors who tried to tell their parents and police that they were being abused, I wasn't believed, either, when I tried speaking up as a teen. I felt so hurt and ignored that adults around me, even the police, were telling me I deserved it, because they were hit, too, as children; I felt suicidal, afterward, and had to comfort myself into not doing it, telling myself that doing that would only be what my parents wanted (since my mother told me I should do it, several times), and that I knew I didn't deserve to be blamed for their marital problems.
 
Children who didn't grow up abused really go further in life: they're more social, have more friends, were able to focus on school (rather than having to focus on trying to cure their depression, brought on by their parents' emotional problems and abusive behavior).

I can't help but be envious of children who grew up with non-abusive parents who helped them, and encouraged them, to attend college, especially ivy league students, with wealthy, college-educated parents.
 
I think that corporal punishment is absolutely abuse if there is any other form of abuse in the child's life that the parents are aware of. There may be room for debate if the parents are otherwise great but that isn't usually the context that sends people here asking questions like this.
 
I think it’s a difficult one because we’re trying to place historical behaviour in a modern society where much more is understood about child development. At the time of my childhood it was usual for children to be hit regularly - smacking or spanking wasn’t seen as an issue and my parents were actively encouraged to hit us as an acceptable form of discipline. My parents would use their hands, hairbrush, slipper etc and the “you’ve done something wrong, you’re going to get smacked” doesn’t really register with me now and isn’t what feels abusive.

The abusive part is where a smacked bottom turned into a full on beating, or where I would be hit until I stopped crying, or having things thrown at me basically where it stopped being about correction (however misguided) and was excessive, with no care or nurture or anything to balance out the message that I was wicked and needed to be battered.

Now, by today’s standards all of that behaviour would be considered abusive but my parents honestly thought some of it was good discipline and part of their job as a parent. I still have feelings about it but that isn’t what I see as abusive.

I guess I’m trying to say that they may have acted with your best interests at heart, may have been following what was then standard parenting advice and may not have intended harm but you still get to have your feelings about it.
 
Children who didn't grow up abused really go further in life: they're more social, have more frie...
Thanks for your insights.
I have gone far in life and am an over achiever, but I feel hollow inside. I have accomplished a lot and am continuing to do so in many ways because I have suffered.
But, I do agree depression holds me back and I struggle with friendships.
 
I think it’s a difficult one because we’re trying to place historical behaviour in a modern society...
Well, so what is confusing is that my mom was calm and said "I love you."
In a way this made it worse and more confusing.
Why isn't it a straight forward discussion?
Yes, being hit with a brush is abuse.
Why does this always illicit a debate?
The addition of an "I love you" and calm approach does not take it out of an abuse context. Calling it a "spanking" doesn't either.

Yet, I cannot get it out of my head that I was bad and I deserved it and my mom did not know any better.
Isn't that bs?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom