• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

What Happens In A Church... Can't Be Talked About With My Therapist?! What?!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Justmehere

Sponsor
I am posting a lot lately, I know. Thanks for being patient with me right now. It is a hard season of life.

I am really embarrassed about this post. It is not only about the stupid horrible things I did, but also really long. I need to share it somewhere.

I really screwed up here.

3 months ago, I got home from an intensive PTSD treatment program that pushed me too far too fast. They meant well, but I came home and I came undone.

The first day back was one of the worst days for me.

The second day back, I was severely dissociative. I had not been that dissociative outside of actual trauma happening or a trauma therapy session. I was losing time and my doctor suggested I use my MP3 player to voice record my day so I would have a way to help me remember. (This is totally legal in my state to do.)

So on the third day, I turned the MP3 player on voice record and I went about my day. I did this for several days and it really helped me not lose so much time while so badly dissociative.

Then went to a Sunday school class. I went at a church that I have gone to regularly for about 2 years. I attended the church prior to that, but only every now and then. For the past two years I built some rally close friendships and let myself be vulnerable enough to tell a couple people I had PTSD, and that I went for intensive treatment for it, and under a community pastors urging, I told two friends I was struggling when I got back. So I risked it.

Unknown to me (at the time) one of these friends told this bible study leader. She did it with good intentions, not maliciously, out of a desire to see me be supported. It wasn't a good idea, but it was what it was.

I didn't know she did that, and just went to the bible study class, with the recorder on.

At the end of the class, they asked for prayer requests. I shared that a friend was very sick and in hospice. Another person and I talked, she was so sweet and said that's awful. Yes, let's pray for that.

The leader jumped in and offered help from the church for my friend and I said thanks but no thanks, I know she doesn't want that already. The church leader offered again and again. I said no each time.

The fourth time, I said "will you please stop?"

She didn't. So I said. "enough, I just asked for prayer for her, I don't need you to continue to give me unasked for advice and keep trying to save her when she doesn't want that and I don't either." I stood up to leave to enforce the boundary. I was also feeling really ashamed that I couldn't say no and have it respected.

The leader thanked me for leaving as I walked out the door. I turned and said, "Thank you? For running in shame?"

I left and broke down sobbing.

The “community pastor" was there and told me they didn't support her actions. This was a miscommunication and I never even figured out what he meant.

I was told not to come back to the study. That was ok, because I didn't want to go back, but yet it wasn't. People knew and asked why didn't I go back.

No one could tell me what I did wrong. No one. I talked to a therapist at a walk in clinic and played the recording of those few short minutes to ask if I had gone crazy and was missing something horrible I did in that moment. They said no...

I moved on, except I didn't. I felt hurt to walk past a room I was banned from without anyone telling me why. It went on for month after month.

I emailed the pastor. I told him I played the recording for another Christian (the walk in therapist happened to be one) professional and no one could tell me what I did wrong. (I think any professional could have reviewed it with me.)

We talked the matter over several times, and I had told him, I am done talking about it. It's not worth all this talking with him and not the leader who did this. Who ran over a clear boundary and badly. He kept saying yeah, she is busy with family matters and she was - a family member was sick. So I had said, then how about we let this go and all move on...

He still asked to again about a project I was doing. I went to meet with him. I had been at the hospital today and had been given bad medical news. I told him, “I'm not well today, I'm massively stressed out and sick, so I need this to be an easy no stress conversation.” We talked about a silly event I put on to make sandwiches for homeless kids and teens. It was fine. He said the church would support it in the future financially, I just needed to call anytime and he would make it happen. We talked of rumors that had been passed around because of my friend who blabbed too much to others. We talked about someone telling me I donated the wrong peanut butter for my own volunteer project at my expense.... We talked about this weird attitude that has grown with the few people my friend talked to about how I was struggling. They seemed to never think I was capable, and the pastor agreed it was off-kilter and the church members should not be critical of what peanut butter jar I buy with my own money for my own volunteer project that I’m fully financially responsible for. It’s just peanut butter.

He seemed to get it, and yet he seemed to be weird. In the moment, I couldn’t place my finger on it. I told him I can't deal with any more. I can't do it. I need space. I started to stand up to leave.

Then he said that he was ready to have me go back to the group, except he had read my email. And in my email, “you mention you recorded the bible study and you played it for someone else.”

I said, “yes, a therapist. We have talked about how I listened to it several times and played it for a therapist. You always tell me not to listen to it over and over and I assure you I listened to it once with a therapist and twice on my own.”

He said, "yeah, you see, you can't go back because you broke trust by recording the bible study and then playing it for someone else."

He said, “the bible study was confidential and it wasn't ok I did that.

I told him, “there was nothing anyone said to indicate it was confidential, no one treated my info with any confidentiality, and additionally, I shared the info with a therapist. No names. They can’t release it. I just talked to a therapist.”

He said. “yeah, you can't do that. How would you feel if I taped this meeting and played it for my therapist?”

“I think that would be a damn good idea! What you do in your therapy is up to you and it’s perfectly legal to record what I say and bring it to your therapy session for your healing process”

He continued on. He confirmed, “even if you had not recorded anything, just talked to the therapist, that is still breaking confidentiality.”

He confirmed no one tells newcomers the rule of confidentiality. Ironically, I have a recording that could prove this too. No one ever says if you come to this church, don’t share anything with your therapist. But he kept telling me I couldn’t talk to the therapist about it.

“You broke trust.”

That's when I lost it.

I told him, “They (the people who cut me down over what peanut butter I bought) never trusted me to buy the right peanut butter. There was no trust in me to break. You broke my trust months ago. YOU TRASHED IT.”

From there the interaction and situation got much worse. But for now, this is as far as I can write and I want to really look at this part that happened. It lead to the rest...

I have some strong feelings about what I did wrong in all of this up to this point. I can actually see his perspective… to a point.

I record because I was dissociative. I have very little memory of anything that whole week in May without the recording helping to bring it back.

If I had to do it again, I would have recorded it, and never told him. I would still talk to the therapist, and I would have told no one.

Is this wrong?

I really think I sabotaged myself and that there are some trauma-reenactment patterns happening. NOT new trauma, but past patterns repeating.

I set a clear boundary. Person in position of power, authority and trust above me pushes the boundary. I speak out to try and keep me safe and have the pain end. Larger group of people confirms the wrong behavior of the person in power and yet decides I’m the bad guy for speaking up about it (in this case to the therapist.) I fumble along and say WAY too much at the wrong moments and open up myself to more hurt. Eventually when I realize I am being scapegoated, I act out even more. Then worse pain happens.

I know the red flags for abusive organizations. I know that several have come up now and I'm struggling with a lot of shock, grief, and confusion about it. Unspoken rules, scapegoating, secrecy, switch and bait (come for one thing, and they have another thing planned), excessive control, etc. These are all red flags that this is not a healthy group.

Any outside feedback on this would be very welcome. I need help to see this clearly. Was I more in the wrong than I realize (up to the point that I have described so far)?
 
Hmmm. I think there is no problem recording yourself for your own purposes - therapy or anything else. I am uncomfortable with the idea that you were recording *other people* . In that case I would expect one to share the fact that you were planning to record, and ask for consent from other people - both to record and then to share it with another party - namely your therapist. before you switched the recorder on. This is somewhat different to keeping a recorded diary of your day when the only voice on record is your own. I don't think it matters that it was a church group as any group or even any individual could object.

From what I see, you made a mistake - I would hope the group would allow you the opportunity to put that right. You state they are Christian - it does not sound like very Christian behaviour to ban you without help.
 
Just to sum up in case I missed or misunderstood something
- You were disassociating & losing time
- You started recording your daily life to assist
- An altercation happened at your church which led to you being banned from bible study that was recorded that you shared with your therapist
- Subsequently you also shared with your church leadership that you had done so ((who appear to be blaming the ban on the recording, yet they didn't know about it at the time you were banned? ))
- Church leadership is now of the opinion that you broke trust & confidentiality by recording bible study
- You were never informed that this policy existed, and are now confused as to whether you weren't informed because it's so normal to expect that, that why would anyone need to be informed ... Or is this unfair // outside feedback requested

Parallel issues with Church
* members you told about your PTSD did not keep that confidential as you had asked
* other members were critical of your execution of a project in which leadership had been impressed with your same execution of said project
* bible study leader insisting on personal information about friend that she had no right to... Possibly out of misunderstanding that this "friend" was not you, yourself,given that there was gossip in the church about your health issues.
* massive double standards in regards to privacy

/////

As far as the recording in general? 6:1, half a dozen of another.

While many people are so possessive of their privacy that they are enacting laws which make it illegal to record someone without their consent (some states so much so that recordings of crimes being committed are inadmissible in court. Sigh. Like mine.) on one side of the extreme, and on the other side there a millions of recordings being made of both your own and others lives not only without second thought, but it is actively encouraged.

Somewhere in the middle of those 2 extremes that it has become common practice to record school lessons from k-12, college lectures, nanny-cams for ones children & pets, church services, musical events, etc. To the point that any public or semi-public gathering, one can readily expect that one or more people is recording whole or in part, where it has not been made illegal to do so. Meanwhile, yes, it is also common practice to ask people not to do so under certain circumstance... Although it is an ask in most places, as there is no legal standing to be able to insist. Conversely, it is also common to ask for consent, in places where it is illegal to do so without consent, to the point of needing to sign waivers giving your consent before being allowed to participate in certain groups/ activities / & other private spaces.

Essentially, a bell curve. Half on consent, half on have at!

***

Ditto, I agree with you, that recording & not having mentioned it would have saved some grief... However, I suspect that as you've been having problems with the church, it would have come out sooner or later in exactly this kind of situation; where he said/ she said is not in play, because you have a durn recording of it!

While recording makes some people distinctly uncomfortable (I'm one, by the way, I actively avoid being recorded!), unless members have been very specifically told *not* to record? Church is one of those places that many many people do record, and even in consent-states most churches happily encourage the practice (just like universities). Sermons for later review, choirs singing, classes to study off of... Except for in specific settings (confession, temple, certain ceremonies, etc.)

I'm more than somewhat irritated that you were banned *before* they knew of the recording, and now that they know? Are trying to make that the reason you were banned. I do think it's telling of the overall problem, though.
 
I think it is Church's fault not to let you know about confidential rules beforehand. Had they told you when you joined them, you would think about going with the recorder or not. Ban from church sounds pretty harsh action to me over someone else's issues and also it adds more to pain that they didn't give you the reasoning either. This is like keeping someone in dark.

It is like they took the total control.
 
It never ceases to amaze me how often you hear about a church leader, someone who has taken upon themselves to spread the word of God to anyone who wants to hear it. To try their best to deliver the message of peace, love, compassion, selflessness and joy.

How can this person then who is suppsed to lead his flock down the path that leads to heaven, by speech as well as by example, blatantly disregard one of the fundamental principles of Christianity?

If this is the example being set by the pastor, I can see why some members of his congregation have little to no respect for others. Looks to me like they are being led astray.

(This is from the Catholic bible, some of the terminology might look a bit odd.)

Matthew 7:
Do not judge, so that you may not be judged. 2 For with the judgment you make you will be judged, and the measure you give will be the measure you get. 3 Why do you see the speck in your neighbor’s[a] eye, but do not notice the log in your own eye? 4 Or how can you say to your neighbor,[b]‘Let me take the speck out of your eye,’ while the log is in your own eye? 5 You hypocrite, first take the log out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to take the speck out of your neighbor’s[c] eye.

Do I think you did something wrong? Nope.

In fact, I commend you for trying to go back and resolve the situation, to "turn the other cheek" so to speak. That can't have been easy.

The pastors reaction to the audio recording is very strange. Why would he care if you play the tape for your therapist? What is he worried about?

I have read this several times now and I'm sorry. Hard as I try, I can't find fault with anything you did.

Oh, I almost forgot. Peanut butter? Really? :bored:

Sounds like you must have been an upstanding member of the the church if buying the wrong peanut butter is the worst thing they could think of. :rolleyes:
 
Thank you @Neverthesame and @Rumors


@Neverthesame - that same section of verses has been on my mind and I have been trying to even apply it to myself before I look at what they did wrong

I woke up crying and shaking this morning. I can't believe this happened. I was supposed to go to a worship night tonight at a friend's house and later meet someone at the church to give them their drill ball that I borrowed. This place was the closets place I had to any family and I want to knew why and how this could happen... I feel awful. I keep thinking what have I done?

After they told me their decisions, the conversation went massively downhill. I screwed up in a huge way. But this part above? What the heck?

I am so used to being the scapegoat.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yeah... I think it is time for a new church. I don't know where to go.

I'm so confused about what to do.

After the conversation got as far as described above, it REALLY fell apart. I went from being banned from the bible study to being banned from the entire church. I am so shaken by that part too... I don't think I can type it all out.

In a nutshell, He talked about having me meet with them with a therapist there, any therapist. I felt like I was losing my mind. I told him I thought that was not allowed! He said it was different if the therapist was there in person. Oh. Really. He said he would pay for it and he would text me or email me to set times up. I did NOT offer to do this. I told him I have no money or resources to arrange this and I am sure my therapist would not be willing. He suggested finding another therapist. At that moment, my mother was calling. I told him I need to go, I need to talk to my mom. I need to talk to her. I need someone else here because this is too much to deal with.

He said he would email me or text me to set up a time to meet up with a therapist or my mother.

I told him I'm not arranging that, and I YELLED no more texts, no more emails, no, do not do that. You can call me but no texts, no emails.

He kept saying he would email me and I became hysterical. I started swearing, screaming, NO do not email or text me this is f*cking ridiculous... yeah. I really lost it. What I did was way out of line and another pastor came over and was there and the both of them were talking to me. I was dissociative. I walked out, leaving my bag and even my service dog behind. I was crying and shaking and I couldn't even remember where I was at moments. I was crying out, what about my privacy and my boundaries which are essential. Stop just leave me alone. They demanded a list of names and dates my privacy had been broken. (One of my clients had heard a rumor that I was mentally ill from someone at the church.) I told them I don't know who but you can not call my clients and keep doing this. Just stop. They kept talking and I went in to get my bag and my dog, and they kept talking. They kept saying they could email me or text me a time for me to come back and solve this with my mother or a therapist. I kept screaming no texts no emails. I was super numb and yet also hysterical.

They told me not to come to church on Sunday because I was screaming at him.... TO NOT TEXT OR EMAIL ME BUT CALL ME IF HE NEEDED TO REACH ME. I left screaming saying to not email or text.

30 minutes later,

I called the church to apologize to the first person. It was wrong what I did. He said thank you and said he would email me to set up a time to meet. I replied, "What will it take for you to understand no means no? Please do not email me. Please do not text me. No. No more emails means no more emails." I hung up.

An hour later, he texted me to tell me he emailed me.

I am not kidding.

Which right now, makes me laugh. Like SERIOUSLY?! You sent a text to tell someone you emailed them after you kicked them out of all church functions for screaming at you to not text or email them?

So much for no meaning no.

I miss my friends so much. They don't do this.


The email he sent said:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
"(Justmehere),
Thank you for calling back and apologizing for the outburst. That means a lot to me. Thank you.

As you suggested, I would be more than happy to connect with one of your third party supporters you suggested. Either your therapist, your counselor, or possibly your mom. Please feel free to ask them a good time for us all to connect so we can better communicate. You had mentioned finances being an issue for getting together with your therapist or counselor and I would like to extend my offer again to pay for that meeting if we need to. I am thankful for you reaching out to me and I look forward to connecting as a group.
Until we are able to resolve this I am asking you not to attend Calvary services or programs. You and I are still able to connect though. As you mentioned today I will not be on the Boulder campus this fall with my new role. So, I am asking you to please make an appointment with me before stopping by so I can meet you in Boulder. I look forward to working through this with you so we can continue what has been a good relationship.
Warmly,

(his name)

(name of church)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------

There is no good relationship.

His texts said I was an excellent person and he looked forward to meeting. He said he would keep my privacy to keep my trust.

Trust? I don't f*ckING TRUST THEM AT ALL. And this is NOT a good relationship. Shit.

I miss my friends so much, I'm thinking of complying.

I am the abused woman drawn to go back to her abuser.

I am thinking of calling some random therapist and seeing if they will come and meet with us. I called three this morning and two were surprisingly willing.

I know that if I tell my trauma therapist, she will flip. She will say you should not go back. We only do trauma work, and do not really deal with problem solving day to day life. I have asked that we focus on trauma work and she is all on board with that.

I don't even want to tell her about this. She doesn't even know I ever spend time with friends at a church.
 
I agree with @Rumors that it sounds like they are making up rules as they go. On one hand, I would understand an "assumed" kind of confidentiality in a group like this, but given your circumstances and knowing it was just shared with a therapist, there should at least be a way to talk about it and come up with a solution that works for you and the group. But the part that is fishy to me is that this excuse for kicking you out came up later, right? Like you were banned before they even found out about the recording, right?

What I'd take from this is that this is not a legitimate source of support, I'm sorry. You are the vulnerable one and they've taken all this miscommunication as a way to shun you, which is horrible. It's just a reminder that humans, church people included, are imperfect. And that's okay. But if you're looking for support you probably have to stick with a few people you know you can trust. And then Bible Study if you want that study, but know any group will be imperfect in some way. Based on what you've written it sounds like you were willing to forgive some imperfections, like the leader being told about your PTSD, but that the leaders here have not given you the same kind of respect and wiggle room.

I'm just really sorry this happened to you. It's sounds pretty unfair and awful.
 
Last edited:
Thanks @Chava

I think you are right on. They did ban me, and I asked to have all freedom back, and they were about to say yes and then said we can't say yes because you said you taped it... I don't them I had no desire to be in the study, I just wanted the public shamming to stop.

What I ended up with was more public shaming, albeit this time I deserved it for screaming at them to stop.

I can find bible studies and church services online...

What I want is to be with my friends, in person. Like we have been doing. Where there is no drama, no stress, and I feel ok.

But I don't think I would ever feel ok there again. I have no where else to go to for any support and until I am accepted back into the church, my friends won't hang with me anymore. They were told to not talk to me and not given a reason why. They are confused and angry and choose to follow the instructions anyhow. I think they knew I was really rattled this week.

I don't understand christians.
 
Don't go back. Not only is there no trust, they are not respecting you at all. Ignoring whether you did anything 'wrong' or not. The fact that they are bending their own rules to fit what they want, the fact that they have repeatedly ignored your own rights, as well as wishes and boundaries. It seems to me that they are manipulating you, just because.

As for missing your friends? Assuming these are friends who didn't spread gossip about you- surely if they really care about you they'll continue to be friends outside of the church environment. If not I'd be questioning if they're your friends at all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom