• We are a multilingual website again. Read the notice about this.
  • Understand AI use at MyPTSD: all AI use is explained in our AI help page. AI use is by choice here. It exists if you want it, but does nothing unless you choose to use it.

Exaggerating Self Blame

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think part of it might come from how much you don't want to be like that, and then fear that you might be a tiny bit like that.

Apparently with ocd you ruminate on your worst fear, i.e. What you find most abhorrent.

The difficulty is that everyone has a little bit of every negative and it's the balance that matters. But it's so hard to judge your own balance.

Does part of your difficulty come from your core belief that you are not as good as you "should" be. My T told me last session, just because you feel guilty doesn't mean you are guilty. I'm struggling to wrap my mind around this one, and I'm not sure why, but it seems relevant for this thread.
 
How can you take things personally but not care? Honest question. I don't get it, but I'm intereste...

Little bit of synergy ;)

I did something... And I didn't know how I felt about it, exactly.

Someone I despised was proud of me, and I was happy about it. Yay. Pat on the head!

Someone I deeply respected was disgusted with me. For the same action.

It made me realize I needed to discriminate who the f*ck I took my cues from. Not all praise is a good thing. Not all condemnation is a bad thing.

Eventually, that process shifted to even if I deeply respect them and they are disgusted by me? But I am satisfied with myself? I did right in my own heart and mind? It doesn't matter what anyone else thinks. At the end of the day I am the one who has to live with the consequences of my own actions/inactions. Not anyone else.

How I don't care? That's because the person talking either doesn't mean anything to me, or I disagree with them.

How I take it personally? Regardless of how little they might mean to me? They struck a nerve. Something I already believe about myself. Although what I believe is usually worse than what they're saying.

It's interesting though, when I replied to Link Removed's question about whether the problem is what I will think of myself or what others will think of me? I was dead serious when I said there is no difference between the two. I've been thinking about what that indicates. Some crossed wires from very early infancy is my guess. Is that something you can relate to at all? I guess I'm kind of seeing you here as a token "person with later trauma who had a good childhood." Hope you don't mind!

Lol. Don't mind at all! ((Although I did just double check to make sure we weren't in the childhood forum! I do try & stay out of there, only end up there on accident, usually. It hurts too much. Everyone here survived their childhoods, and I don't know if my son will. Or what he'll look like if he does. And from the other side of it, have been up to my eyeballs in childhood & developmental trauma between him & his cousins for years.))

Simply put, yep. Can totally relate to that. There have been times in my life where either that is straight up true, or -like dealing with family courts- one of my biggest struggles is not allowing that to be true, again. Because the toehold is "I am what you believe I am." ((Me stuff / trauma stuff)) Coupled with "Your opinion is deeply important to me, because your decision affects my child." So it skirts my defenses, and lands right where I live.

I have to work really, really damn hard to create that distance when that happens. Sometimes to the point of going cold & completely shutting off all of my emotions. If I'm lucky. Sometimes I can't, and I don't just burn with all the shame, despair, guilt, guilt, guilt of the moment of whatever they could/might/do think of me... But all of the shame, despair, & guilt from the past. Every past blame. Every past guilt. I'm more of a monster than these people will ever know. What they're accusing me of? Pfft. May not be true in the slightest. But the guilt, shame, and need for their good opinions? Which gives them power over me? Guts me. Shreds me. I completely lose who I am. I am pain.

Before I learned to laugh & say f*ck You :sneaky: ? ...I go back to being what I was. I am whatever you say I am. Whatever is needed. Whatever is wanted. Without form or substance. I have no opinions. No thoughts. No desires. I am nothing, but pure unending pain. And I will be whatever you need me to be.

Although one thing to remember is I have complex trauma. Helluva lot of combat vets do. Shrug. IDK if that plays a part, or if it's just PTSD, or just me.
 
Last edited:
I go into a spin examining and scrutinizing any tendencies of my own to be the same way that I was "judging" them for
Yes, exactly. In fact, I can strongly relate to just about everything in your post.

I've, finally, come to realize that I am different from my mother in that I apologized to my children when I knew I had screwed up.
Yes, I've come to realize that too for myself. But nagging doubt keeps creeping in, especially given that my daughter is at a stage (hopefully a stage) where she refuses to have anything to do with me. And I know approaching her would be a bad idea, not only because it's obvious she wants space, but because I know her aloofness would trigger me and I wouldn't be able to relate to her in the way I'd like to. And you see, I recently cut my own mother out of my life because of a long history that she absolutely refuses to face and take responsibility for. There is a difference: I didn't do the same things to my daughter that my mother did to me, and I took responsibility for the things I did do. But the pattern of lack of contact continues regardless. And then I read so many posts here where people have absolutely impossible family members and the advice is usually "they'll never change, walk away" and every time I see that I think not so much about my mother as about myself and wonder how my daughter sees me and whether if she were to tell people how she sees me, she would be given the same advice. And that would mean that indeed I am impossible, will never change, and people should walk away from me.

And I displayed MANY other different positive behaviors toward my children that my mother never modeled for me.
Good you can see that.

My therapist recently surprised me by saying I have a tendency to exaggerate the negative about myself and that I wasn't nearly as bad a mother as I think I was, and told me to go home and think about all the happy times. :confused:

My mom continues to believe she raised us the "right" way and doesn't see anything wrong with it.
There was a thread a while back where someone was worrying about she might be a narcissist because she had up till then thought she was a pretty good mother, but then started wondering because her own mother, who was a narcissist, would have said she was a pretty good mother too. The one answer I remember was someone saying that the fact that she was worrying about it was a pretty good indicator that she wasn't. A narcissist doesn't see anything wrong with how they are, by definition.

My mind can still come up with a lot of "yes, but's" about that one though.

Is this a way to keep myself from the truth of how painful it is/was to be around some people and accept their poor treatment of me?
Maybe, I don't know.

if you insist
In this case, I do. Thank you. I appreciate your comments, even if I don't necessarily agree.

Other people may not be interested in being aware that they are manipulative or may be consciously trying to be manipulative.
Right, that's another example like the above about the narcissistic mother.

Where is the line though? Is there a way to stop the incessant self examination and just relax a bit?

Apparently with ocd you ruminate on your worst fear
So this is maybe an OCD thing? Hmm... (I'm not sure whether that means it needs to be treated differently, but it's an interesting observation.)

But it's so hard to judge your own balance.
Yes, exactly.

Does part of your difficulty come from your core belief that you are not as good as you "should" be
Not exactly. It's more about the consequences if I am not as good as I should be. For me, that means I will be abandoned. I'm struggling for the right words, it's more complicated, and bigger, than that. But that is the general idea. When I said I can't separate what I think of myself from what others think of me, it was significant. What others think of me can have a huge impact on me, not just because of their opinion but what they might do with it and how that affects me. What I am learning from exploring this is mainly how extraordinarily vulnerable I am to other people's actions. Even if those actions are ones that others might not care much about. "Shrug and walk away" is such easy advice to give. When I think about the possibility of someone being given the advice to deal with me that way? Panic. My mother did exactly that, including in life-threatening situations. Shrug and walk away. I think about this and, well, I can't think. I can be hurt so easily. That's the problem here.

just because you feel guilty doesn't mean you are guilty
Did your therapist tell you how to tell the difference?

@FridayJones, I read your post and am thinking about it. Thank you for sharing all that. I'll leave responding till a little later, I need to go out and do some stuff.
 
In general I experience negative feelings much more consistently and easily than negative ones. But I don't try to erase what seem like negative traits. I'm pretty aware that I'm a mess, but also full of goodness too. I like the idea of becoming whole through embracing our dark and light parts. I used to beat myself up a lot for personal flaws and failures but it was too exhausting because I was really messed up and screwing up in all directions.

Not sure if that's helpful. I do have issues with self concept and I relate to some of this too, but I also find it freeing to just be honest with myself about where I'm far from perfect. It seems like when I'm exaggerating or full of fear that it's actually connected more to fears of rejection than anything else. I personally don't care if I'm a mess...but when I sense I'm too much of mess for others I easily feel shame and start to conflate and inflate things (the all-consuming "I'm a loser piece of shit" kind of message).
 
It made me realize I needed to discriminate who the f*ck I took my cues from.
Yes, of course. And honestly, that is true for me too. If I don't care about someone, their opinion is much less important. It gets confusing when I have conflicting views of the same person. (Oh no... there's that "parts" thing again!)

Everyone here survived their childhoods, and I don't know if my son will.
:cry:
That sums it up better than any words... except maybe "don't give up yet."

Because the toehold is "I am what you believe I am." ((Me stuff / trauma stuff)) Coupled with "Your opinion is deeply important to me, because your decision affects my child." So it skirts my defenses, and lands right where I live.
Right, okay. So maybe I was wrong about where this comes from, except for the way it affects me personally. I mean, your defenses will be down in different places from mine, but there is an Achilles heel regardless.

What they're accusing me of? Pfft. May not be true in the slightest. But the guilt, shame, and need for their good opinions? Which gives them power over me? Guts me. Shreds me. I completely lose who I am. I am pain.
Wow. I can relate to this. So very much. It may not even be true, but it doesn't really matter. It hurts just the same.
 
I personally don't care if I'm a mess...but when I sense I'm too much of mess for others I easily feel shame and start to conflate and inflate things (the all-consuming "I'm a loser piece of shit" kind of message).
So it sounds like you don't care about having negative traits so long as they don't affect anyone, but the exception is when you feel like you are too much for others? Is that right?

It's seeming like each of us has an Achilles heel, and others can "get" us by aiming there... even if they don't mean to.
 
What I am learning from exploring this is mainly how extraordinarily vulnerable I am to other people's actions. Even if those actions are ones that others might not care much about. "Shrug and walk away" is such easy advice to give. When I think about the possibility of someone being given the advice to deal with me that way? Panic. My mother did exactly that, including in life-threatening situations. Shrug and walk away. I think about this and, well, I can't think. I can be hurt so easily. That's the problem here.

Perhaps the hurt is justified.

Yes, people keep telling me that. "That was then, now is different... No, it isn't. I don't think this is based on the past. It's reality. My hypervigilance makes absolute sense to me based on the present. People do react based on what they think of us. .

Agreed.

It came to my memory, I once asked someone to use their contact on a no-SI contract. They said don't call for anything but that. When I did once they never even got back to me. (No need to say more there. Oh well.)

But is that 'self-blame-worthy', to be vulnerable?

Hard to reconcile what people say we are all worth yet their actions state otherwise.

Hugs to you @sun seeker. :hug: :hug:
 
I have another angle on this exaggerated self-blame cycle that I've noticed before in myself but have a hard time grasping completely. I will try to explain well enough to be understood.

It has to do with the worry that "I might have said something/acted too (whatever)" and hurt someone. It's usually a small instance during a conversation that, later, when I go over the conversation in my head, I have the perspective that maybe "I said something too..." and they might have taken something the wrong way and been hurt.

I've realized that for myself there are small misunderstandings in what is spoken to me that come across in conversations. My own internal boundaries accept or discard what the other person is saying. If someone is upset about something and gets heated, maybe says things that are rash. My inner boundaries weigh the true meaning of the situation and I am not necessarily hurt.

I realized that other people can have this discernment when hearing things I say or do, their inner boundaries can protect them. I can let them/trust them to have those boundaries. In fact, if I get too overprotective/apologetic about every little thing, that doesn't allow them those boundaries (or, their boundaries can tell them to just ignore that in me for now lol!).

To assume that no discernment is there (to whatever degree), is to place an expectation of perfection between us.
As in: "I have to behave perfectly so I don't hurt anyone. If I don't behave perfectly I will hurt some one." This places the control of the relationship with me instead of with both of us. I need to allow the other person to be responsible for their own protection.

So, even though it looks like I am being super worried about hurting others, it can lead to not allowing them their own half of the relationship.
(not everyone is a narcissist who wants me to take all the blame!)

That was hard to write out, hope it made sense somewhere.
 
That was hard to write out, hope it made sense somewhere.
Absolutely it did, and it fits with some of what I worked on in therapy today in an indirect way. For me there has always been a "yes but..." when I considered this very valid point about not being responsible for how other people take things. The problem was I could be so very easily hurt by another person's misinterpretation, so had to be hypervigilant even if I knew on a cognitive level that I could not control how people filtered what I said or did. I just began to see today that this has begun to shift, and that it is becoming safer to be true to myself and let others be responsible for their own interpretation. Interesting timing with this thread!
 
Cool, I get that! Yes, that's it isn't it. Safer to be true to myself - that seems to be the crux of every problem.

The timing of this thread is great. I have been thinking about starting a thread like this several times in the last month but didn't know what the title would be or how I would explain myself!
 
My own internal boundaries accept or discard what the other person is saying

I had a "friend" who used to say
"I am not responsible for your emotions....you are responsible for your own emotions"
It took me years to understand and accept the meaning in this.

I couldn't accept it at first because my abusers were responsible for damaging me (my emotions). If they weren't responsible, but instead I was????

But, over time, I came to accept that outside of the exception of abusive situations (and maybe a few other exceptions) it is true. It is my responsibility to have boundaries and to filter for what was intended, rather than what I interpreted.

It took years, and I'm still working on it but I think there is some good stuff in it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Donation drives

2026 Donation Goal

Goal
$1,800.00
Earned
$910.00
This donation drive ends in
0 hours, 0 minutes, 0 seconds
  50.6%

Trending content

Featured content

Back
Top Bottom